Manildra lied about employment figures to pass ethanol legislation

Ethanol producer Manildra has been forced to clarify figures, following revelations it falsified numbers given to the NSW government when lobbying for new legislation.


The bill was introduced to parliament by innovation and better regulation Minister, Victor Dominello, who told parliament the reform would create 3000 jobs and flow-on into 20,000 indirect jobs.

The bill passed and sets a target of ethanol to account for six per cent of all petroleum sales. The initial figure was supplied to Minister Dominello by Manildra, one of Australia’s leading ethanol producers, but has been proven a gross exaggeration.

Minister Dominello has since corrected the figure for parliamentary records, reducing that figure to just 281 jobs and 2668 indirect jobs created by the scheme.

Speaking with the press, Minister Dominello said the numbers were “sourced from a confidential Deloitte Access Economics report commissioned by the Biofuels Association of Australia,”

“Upon examination of the report, I realised the figures I quoted were incorrect and I have sought to correct the parliamentary record at the first available opportunity.”

Pressure continues to mount against the state government, following Fairfax Media’s exposure of more than $160,000 in donations were made to the Coalition government, and 20 private meetings were secured during their lobbying efforts.

Jeremy Buckingham, NSW Greens MP, is outraged at the ongoing conflict of interest. He said:

“It’s deeply disturbing that the minister in charge of fair trading would mislead the parliament with false figures spoon[fed] to him by a major political donor who stands to benefit by hundreds of millions of dollars. Many MPs cited jobs involved to justify support for legislation they knew was deeply flawed.”

Some say that the necessity for more equipment will force smaller retailers to raise petrol prices to cope with the rise in ethanol-mixed fuel sales.

One thought on “Manildra lied about employment figures to pass ethanol legislation

  1. So The facts are undeniable. Meetings with the Government 20. It was commented that 6 was extraordinary but 20 is getting ridiculous. A piece of legislation that guarantees 268 direct jobs that has the potential to add $0.08c per litre of Petrol in NSW. A $0.38c tariff on imported ethanol to protect the market. This does not guarantee fuel security because we are only talking about 6% of Petrol, not the Diesel market. If oil was stopped tomorrow this “Mandate” would do absolutely nothing for fuel in NSW. What is it there for? Protect jobs? 268 direct jobs that have been subsidised in one way or another over the last decade. A mandate in the US caused corn prices to be driven up in Mexico which caused a food shortage in that country. I am not saying that will happen in NSW but I am saying that a Mandate is not the environmental, jobs or fuel security magic bullet it is made out to be. This whole piece of legislation is about money, money getting to people who can get access to governments and have the means to pressure governments to get legislation that benefits them. Look up Manildra’s private owner. This looks like the rich getting richer and the workers paying for it.

Comments are closed.

Next Post

2016 Mercedes-AMG C 63 S Coupe on sale in Australia from $162,400

The 2016 Mercedes-AMG C 63 S Coupe has touched down in Australia, coming in as the company’s new muscle coupe next to the popular sedan. Like the sedan counterpart, the coupe in Australia is only available in ’S’ form. This means it comes with the higher-tune 4.0-litre twin-turbo V8 engine […]

Subscribe Us Now